The research offers several important considerations. Studies of faculty time suggest that online instruction often redistributes faculty effort toward feedback and individualized communication. Research on class size finds that modest increases may have little effect in some courses, though no single cap fits every course. Community college equity research and federal interaction rules both underscore the importance of close instructor support. As we think about online seat caps, these considerations suggest protecting our gateway courses, where our students may benefit most from that support.
Faculty workload
Class size and outcomes
Equity gaps
Federal RSI rules
This page is meant to support our conversation. Move the slider to a section size to explore illustrative success-rate scenarios for face-to-face and online sections in three kinds of courses.
Building a culture of excellence in online learning
The research and my experience with online learning point to the same idea: students do their best when they feel an instructor is truly with them. We may not be there in every section yet, but I believe we can get there by investing in our faculty and setting shared expectations for connecting with students, rather than by increasing section sizes. I trust this team to weigh that alongside our budget and enrollment realities and decide what is best for our students and for Pitt.
Scenario illustration, not a forecast. The success-rate curves below are generated from editable assumptions about baseline success, interaction thresholds, and changes per additional seat. They do not predict Pitt student outcomes and should not be interpreted as effects caused by class size. Replace the assumptions with institution-specific estimates only after an appropriate analysis. Here, “success” means earning a C or better; confirm Pitt's institutional definition before use. See Model assumptions.
515253550
30seats
Illustrative success-rate scenarios by section size
Face-to-faceOnlineExample enrollment range: 20-30 students
What the research says
Online teaching changes how faculty time is spent. Studies report substantial online grading, feedback, and individual communication demands, although findings about total time per student are mixed. Faculty workload should be evaluated by course design and expected interaction, not modality alone (Van de Vord & Pogue, 2012; Hislop & Ellis, 2004).
Modest increases did not reduce outcomes in one large experiment. At DeVry University, online sections averaging approximately 10% more than 31 students showed little measurable effect on course success or subsequent persistence. The finding is relevant but should not be assumed to apply unchanged to every community college course (Bettinger et al., 2017).
Course purpose matters. A synthesis of 58 studies found that sections of 40 or more may be appropriate for foundational knowledge with limited individual interaction, while 15 or fewer may better support higher-order thinking and complex skill development. These are context-dependent guidelines, not universal caps (Taft, Kesten & El-Banna, 2019).
Some community college students experience larger online performance gaps. A Washington State study of nearly 500,000 course enrollments found larger online-versus-face-to-face performance differences for younger students, male students, Black students, and students with lower GPAs. The largest adjusted subject-area gaps included social sciences and applied professions. The study did not test the effect of changing online section caps (Xu & Jaggars, 2014).
Federal rules require regular and substantive interaction in distance education. Under 34 CFR 600.2, institutions must provide predictable opportunities for substantive instructor-student interaction and monitor academic engagement and success, with prompt proactive instructional engagement when needed or requested. The regulation does not establish a numerical online class cap or require every interaction to begin with the instructor (34 CFR 600.2).
A suggested interim path for Pitt. This is an institutional recommendation, not a research-proven universal standard. Consider retaining current online gateway-course caps until course-level outcomes, feedback demands, and faculty capacity are reviewed. Where an increase is appropriate, pair it with a quality-reviewed course design, an explicit interaction plan, and a defined post-implementation review. Set caps according to course-level learning outcomes, pedagogy, student support needs, faculty capacity, and observed Pitt outcomes rather than one college-wide number.
Model assumptions (scenario inputs)
In this illustrative scenario, success declines gradually as enrollment increases, with the decline becoming more pronounced near an assumed interaction threshold. Neither the threshold nor the relationship is an empirically validated prediction. The online baseline gap and any difference between online and face-to-face thresholds are scenario inputs, not federal requirements or research-established constants. Feedback hours are a transparent arithmetic scenario: enrollment × assumed individual feedback minutes per student per week ÷ 60. That assumption covers individualized written or recorded feedback on student work only, not preparation, general grading, facilitation, or outreach. Inputs are limited to realistic ranges.
Course type
Assumed face-to-face baseline success (%)
Assumed threshold (seats)
Assumed decline per added seat (points)
Assumed online gap (points)
Assumed online threshold offset (seats)
Assumed individual feedback minutes per student per week